The following is a Guest Post submitted for publication by former Concrete Craft franchisee Corey Chase.
Guest Post Disclaimer: The opinions, statements, and content expressed in this guest post and other Guest Posts are solely those of the guest writer(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views, opinions, or endorsements of the publisher or this website. Statements of fact have not been verified.
The Collapse of a Franchise System
Concrete Craft once promoted more than 100 successful locations. Today, its parent
confirms the business has stopped operating. Former owners deserve more than a
farewell page. By Corey Chase
Concrete Craft’s website now leads to a brief farewell. The statement is unambiguous: “Concrete Craft is no
longer operating as a business.” Home Franchise Concepts, its parent company with a California office in
Irvine, thanks customers and franchise owners and provides a contact email. Concrete Craft is also absent
from HFC’s current list of franchise opportunities.
For families who invested in the brand, that notice raises questions it does not answer. What happened to
the businesses? When did management recognize the problems? What did prospective buyers know? And
who will account for the money, work, and livelihoods invested in a system that has disappeared?
My wife, Maureen, and I purchased the Bluffton, South Carolina, territory in 2020 through CCMC Holdings
LLC. We believed we were building a future for our family with the backing of an established franchise
system. Our experience forms part of draft arbitration counterclaims against American Decorative Coatings
LLC, which operated as Concrete Craft, and Home Franchise Concepts. Those allegations remain to be
decided.
The growth story and the ending
In May 2021, Concrete Craft’s own recruitment website promoted more than 100 successful franchise
locations across North America. It emphasized national backing, training, marketing, and techniques
intended to distinguish franchisees from independent competitors.
Its March 2024 franchise disclosure document gives another snapshot: 77 U.S. outlets at the end of 2023.
The accompanying financial statements identify 80 operating territories when three Canadian territories
are included.
Those figures have different geographic and reporting bases. Nevertheless, the distance between the
company’s growth message and its current shutdown announcement demands explanation. Sean Kelly,
writing for UnhappyFranchisee in April 2026, reported that the brand’s location directory had reached zero.
His reporting also identified former owners continuing under independent names.
That distinction matters. A franchise system can disappear while some contractors survive by abandoning
its name. Their survival does not explain why the system they paid to join ended.
When the product becomes the liability
Our draft counterclaims describe more than 90 repair or recall jobs over one to two years after overlay
failures began in 2021. We allege that Concrete Craft repeatedly attributed those failures to installation
mistakes.
The Collapse of a Franchise System | Corey Chase
Returning to a failed project consumes the same resources needed to earn revenue on the next one:
employees, materials, equipment, and time. It also puts the local owner’s reputation at risk with customers
who purchased a finished surface and reasonably expect it to last.
In an account prepared for our attorney, I described how the franchisee Facebook group changed our
understanding. Owners compared photographs, project histories, and reports involving materials supplied
by vendors. Problems we had been told were individual mistakes appeared across multiple territories.
According to our account, after owners collectively challenged the installer-error explanation, responsibility
shifted toward vendors. Our draft counterclaims describe alleged widespread failures involving vendors’
products and only partial compensation.
The chronology deserves scrutiny: when complaints arrived, what explanations owners received, when
management recognized a broader problem, and how reimbursement was calculated. Those answers
should be recoverable from communications and project records.
The disputed promise of a proprietary system
We bought into Concrete Craft believing we were purchasing meaningful advantages: specialized products,
training, operating knowledge, and continuing support. Our counterclaims challenge whether those
advantages were delivered as represented.
The draft counterclaims allege that several products represented as proprietary were actually white-labeled
materials available from outside suppliers. They identify AeroKoat, RubberKoat, RenewKoat, RestoreKoat,
and PebbleKoat and dispute the uniqueness of the system sold to franchise buyers.
Selling private-label products is not, by itself, proof of deception. The question is whether the company
accurately described what buyers were purchasing and the competitive advantage it supplied.
A franchise buyer needs to know whether substantial fees purchase exclusive know-how, preferential
access, validated processes, or branding around materials available elsewhere. Those are different
investments. A sales presentation should make the difference clear.
Our claims also challenge the training. I describe receiving limited instruction on small sample boards,
insufficient preparation for large outdoor installations, and promised regional training that did not
materialize. I paid vendors to provide instruction at actual jobs and allege that even vendor-led installations
failed.
Following the money
The financial burden extended beyond repairs. The draft counterclaims allege misuse of national
advertising contributions contrary to restrictions in the franchise agreement. That remains a disputed claim
requiring examination of the fund’s actual expenditures.
There is also a purchasing issue. A September 2026 account prepared for counsel describes a comparison
between a vendor invoice and Concrete Craft’s invoice that appeared to show a percentage markup on
freight, in addition to the product markup.
The underlying invoices still need to be assembled and checked. The issue is whether the amount presented
as shipping accurately reflected the charge, and whether an additional margin was disclosed and
authorized.
These questions require records: original vendor invoices, freight bills, purchasing agreements, advertising-
fund ledgers, and the disclosures buyers received. They should not be resolved by assurances from either
side.
Concrete Craft’s own financial statements provide a further warning sign. They report a $730,427 net loss
for 2023, including $881,981 in allocated parent expenses. Management stated that HFC had committed to
support operating expenses through February 27, 2025.
That date does not establish when support actually ended. It does make the financing and wind-down
timeline an essential part of understanding the collapse.
The families behind the closures
We ceased operating in March 2023 and later sold the business because we could not see a way out of the
continued failure of jobs and projects. Our draft counterclaims describe a proposed relocation to Florida
that did not go forward after Concrete Craft said the relevant territories had already been sold. For our
family, the journey ended with the loss of the business we had worked to build and the need to find a way
forward.
Through the Concrete Craft community, I personally know people who lost their homes, saw their
marriages break down, or went bankrupt as their businesses failed. These are accounts from people I know.
The consequences extend to spouses, children, employees, and others whose lives were tied to those
businesses.
I also personally know of two franchise owners who died by suicide. Their Concrete Craft business failures
allegedly contributed to the circumstances surrounding their deaths, but that connection has not been
independently established. It would be irresponsible to assign a single cause to either death. I believe their
business failures played a serious role, while recognizing that the connection remains unproven. Their loss
deserves acknowledgment with care for their families.
A location count cannot capture those experiences. The closure of a franchise system leaves questions
about what happened to the people who trusted it, whether warnings that might have protected them
were disclosed in time, and who at the administrative level knew about the deteriorating conditions within
the organization.
Counterclaims and disputed remedies
The draft also addresses a release associated with the transfer and disputes its enforceability. Exiting a
failing franchise can therefore leave an owner confronting another fight over what remedies remain
available.
The draft counterclaims further allege that approximately eighteen other Concrete Craft franchisees
previously resolved materially similar claims. That assertion requires the underlying records; a settlement
alone would not establish a finding of fraud.
Our dispute involves arbitration, where claims and defenses can unfold outside a public courtroom. That
makes reporting on the available evidence especially important. The disappearance of the brand should not
end scrutiny of what was sold, what was delivered, and how owners were treated when they tried to leave.
Accountability after the brand disappears
Public reporting has widened scrutiny of HFC. In July 2026, The American Prospect reported that 54 Kitchen
Tune-Up and Bath Tune-Up franchisees had filed FTC complaints alleging substantial losses and misleading
practices. A spokesperson for HFC’s owner, JM Family Enterprises, declined substantive comment to that
publication because of ongoing litigation.
Those complaints concern separate brands. They provide context for scrutiny of the parent company, but
do not establish Concrete Craft’s liability. An FTC investigation is reportedly underway but remains private,
according to information supplied by the author. Its existence, scope, and status have not been
independently confirmed for this article. An investigation would not itself establish wrongdoing, and the
sources reviewed do not establish a fraud judgment against Concrete Craft.
Concrete Craft’s closure is nevertheless established by the parent’s own announcement. What remains
unresolved is responsibility for the conditions leading to it.
HFC should provide a documented account of the wind-down, the disposition of franchise agreements, its
response to product failures, and the financial treatment of affected owners. The farewell page offers no
such accounting.
A business system sold through promises of support and national strength should face scrutiny when that
system vanishes. Former owners are entitled to have their allegations examined on the evidence.
Prospective franchise buyers deserve to understand what happened before trusting the next growth story.
Are you familiar with Concrete Craft franchise and its franchisees?
What happened?
What do you think? Feel free to share a comment below.
INVITATION: All individuals and companies discussed on this site are invited to provide corrections, clarifications, explanations, rebuttals or opinions. They may do so in the comment section below, by emailing us at UnhappyFranchisee[at]Gmail[dot]com or both.
TAGS: Home Franchise Concepts, HFC, JM Family Enterprises, Concrete Craft, Franchises for Veterans, Veterans franchise, franchise Truth for Veterans, AdvantaClean franchise, Aussie Pet Mobile franchise, Bath Tune-Up franchise, Budget Blinds franchise, Kitchen Tune-Up franchise, Lightspeed Restoration franchise, PremierGarage franchise, The Tailored Closet franchise, Two Maids franchise
Relatively few franchise sellers blatantly provide outright false financial representations. Far more provide selective, partial,…
Great news from the Federal Trade Commission! Could DonutNV be next? Read the Press Release…
The Koala Insulation franchise was founded by Scott Marr and franchise attorney Keith Gross. Koala…
Koala Insulation was founded by Scott Marr and now-former congressional candidate and franchisee attorney Keith…
The Wallaby Windows franchise was founded by Scott Marr and Keith Gross, promoted by Franchise…
The embattled mini-donut franchise seller has filed its Franchise Disclosure Document (FDD) in a single…