The NYPD Pizza franchise system has a proven track record, according to New York Pizza Development CEO Paul Russo.

The question is:  Does the NYPD Pizza franchise have a track record of franchise success… or franchise failure, lost investments and unhappy franchisees?

NYPD Pizza CEO Paul Russo is quoted in a recent press release that announces that his company is now in cahoots with Beautiful Brands (BBI):

“NYPD is the perfect formula for franchise success,” Russo said. “Not only have all of our proprietary ingredients been fully developed with nationwide distribution in place, we have a proven track record with 28 best pizza awards nationwide to show for it.”

If NYPD Pizza has the “perfect formula for franchise success,” why has the franchise chain shrunk nearly 60% since 2008?

Why does the search term “NYPD Pizza CLOSED” reveal failed NYPD Pizza locations in California, Florida, Colorado, New Mexico, and Texas?

NYPD Pizza Franchise Chain has Shrunk 59% Since 2008

The perfect formula for franchise success?

In 2008, PMQ magazine stated that NYPD Pizza had 17 locations.

The NYPD Pizza franchise website currently lists only 6 locations as open:

  • AR  Little Rock
  • FL  Orlando (Universal Blvd)
  • FL  Orlando (College Park)
  • FL  Orlando  (South Hiawassee Rd.)
  • FL  The Villages
  • FL Winter Garden

That’s a unit decline of nearly 60%.

Some cursory Internet searching revealed what looks like at least 21 NYPD franchise locations* that are no longer in business:

NYPD Pizza Locations No Longer in Business
CA AntiochCA Burbank

CA Fullerton

CA Pleasant Hill

CA San Marcos

CO Colorado Springs

FL Kissimmee

FL Navarre

FL Orlando (Orange Ave.)

FL Orlando (S. Alafaya Trail)

FL Poinciana

FL St. Augustine

FL Tampa (Channelside)

NM AlbuquerqueSC Mt. Pleasant

SC Summerville

UT Draper

UT Layton

UT Murray

UT Park City

UT West Valley

TX Mesquite

This is not a complete nor infallible list.  Please add locations, details, circumstances or corrections below.

NYPD Pizza Partners With Beautiful Brands:  Let the HypeFest Begin!

So now Beautiful Brands has announced that it will be pushing NYPD Pizza franchise opportunities along with its other questionable and troubled franchise brands.

Of course, Beautiful Brands founder David Rutkauskas positions NYPD Pizza as a budding success story despite the fact it’s been struggling for several years and was, in fact, founded by conman Lou Pearlman who is in a federal prison for perpetrating the largest Ponzi scheme in Florida’s history.

“This is a franchise success story just waiting to happen,” said David Rutkauskas, BBI founder, president and CEO. “Not only is the cuisine incredible, but everything about the business model spells enormous customer appeal…”

If ever there were a franchise opportunity that prompted the warning caveat emptor (Let the buyer beware), this would be it.

ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH THE NYPD PIZZA FRANCHISE OPPORTUNITY OR PAUL RUSSO? 

ARE YOU FAMILIAR WITH BEAUTIFUL BRANDS OR DAVID RUTKAUSKAS?

PLEASE SHARE A COMMENT BELOW.

Contact UnhappyFranchisee.com

Also Read:

BEAUTIFUL BRANDS Franchise Complaints

CAMILLE’S SIDEWALK CAFE Franchise Complaints

unhappyzee

Recent Posts

Scott Marr’s WALLABY WINDOWS Franchise:  What Happened?

The Wallaby Windows franchise was founded by Scott Marr, husband of franchise attorney & Congressional…

6 days ago

Congressional Candidate Keith Gross’ Law Firm Denied Injunction Against Military Veterans, Alleged Fraud Victims

Gross Law, the Panama City Beach, FL law firm owned by an attorney running for…

2 weeks ago

The Donut Days Are Over: DonutNV Franchise Update, Summer 2026 (UPDATED)

The DonutNV Franchise Report chronicles, in real time, one of the most public, documented and…

4 weeks ago

Gross Law Group Sues the Mother of a Severely Anorexic Child for its Donut Client

On May 22 and May 23rd, 2026, Gross Law Firm, on behalf of controversial and…

4 weeks ago

Gross Law Group Sues Air Force Veterans for Donut Client

Upfront Clarification:  Congressional candidate Keith Gross, who founded and heads Gross Law Group P.A.,  has…

4 weeks ago

Gross Law Files a Dozen Lawsuits Against DonutNV Franchisees

Gross Law Group P.A. of Panama City, FL, on behalf of franchisor DonutNV Franchising Inc.,…

4 weeks ago